A state body stopped accepting appeals from the public via email after officials raised concerns over error-filled and irrelevant correspondence generated by AI.
The Office of the Commissioner for Environmental Information (OCEI) policy now only allows appeals through its website or by post.
The move came as the OCEI was bombarded with material created by AI, some of which was inaccurate or irrelevant.
The office deals with appeals in requests for environmental information under what are known as the AIE Regulations.
Internal correspondence said the OCEI needed to give more thought to combating the use of artificial intelligence by applicants.
One message from an official said: “A question that has been raised is whether we in OCEI (and our colleagues in [the Information Commissioner]) should give more thought to having appellants use the webform only when submitting their appeals – rather than giving them the option of email.
“I understand [the] Ombudsman and SIPO have already taken this approach, and the idea is that it cuts down on the lengthy AI generated appeals/complaints.”
However, the official questioned whether it would have any impact given a person could just copy and paste text from AI into the webform.
A colleague said at the very least it would help in better organising the information.
“[It] makes it quicker to scan for the actual submission, sometimes the appeals can be so lengthy you are at risk of missing something or misinterpreting it, as it stands,” an email said.
Another official said using the webform already only allowed a limited wordcount.
They said this could “minimise … abuse of AI-aided appeals” but that exceptions needed to be made for people who were not “tech savvy.”
Their message said: “I do think it’s [a] positive move and whilst we haven’t seen a great deal of these types of appeals, I have no doubt they are coming.”
One staff member said forcing people to appeal in a certain way could raise issues around “accessibility.”
They wrote: “Perhaps … retain other methods of applying but to encourage use of webform, particularly in light of the public sector duty under the Equality Act.”
Another official said there was also a chance that AI would be used anyway to “flood” the OCEI with appeals through the website.
However, each appeal requires payment of a €50 fee and how artificial intelligence might be used to clear that hurdle was not discussed in the records.
Asked about the changes made in April, an OCEI spokesperson said: “We have no evidence to suggest that AI is a risk in terms of automated appeals.
“However, like many other appeals bodies and complaint handlers we have seen a significant increase in the use of AI in submissions and correspondence in appeals to our Office.
“Our experience has shown that AI-generated correspondence can be inaccurate and can contain large volumes of material which is irrelevant in the context of the service we provide.”
The spokesperson said appeals could be made by webform or post and their access officer would provide help to anybody with a disability who required additional assistance.
“We are fully satisfied that the appeal process remains accessible,” they said.